With one of my friends, I pretended to talk about some secret club, while I knew that Alisha was eavesdropping. It was just a little joke, but Alisha totally bought it and was intrigued by this secret club. I decided to be even more secretive about it, partly because I hadn’t really thought of having to elaborate it yet and partly because it seemed to make her even more interested.
I told her to come to my place that same evening if she wanted to know more about the club.
“Tell me, what is it?”
“Well, it’s a secret club, but I can’t really tell you any more than that”.
She looked at me and pleaded “Come on, who is part of it? Is it a party club?”
“Did you notice that I always get better grades than you do?” I asked her, trying to intrigue her even more. Her mouth went open in amazement and she nodded. Apparently she thought I had some secret trick to getting better grades, besides studying hard.
“I could tell you, but…” I paused for effect.
“But what?” she asked.
“But I need to make sure you won’t tell anyone” I said.
“I promise! Totally!” she said. “That’s not enough” I said, “I need some assurance.”
I took my phone out and took a picture of her. If you want me to tell you, I need you to take your shirt off while I take a picture of you. She grabbed her shirt but then paused for a moment. “And you’ll not show it to anyone if I keep my secret?” she asked. I nodded.
She took her shirt off wihle I took a picture. Apparently the attraction of some secret club was so strong that she would immediately take a chance and trust me.
“Those too” I said and pointed to her shorts. She paused for a moment again and then started taking her shorts off too without any protest.
I took some pictures and checked the quality on my phone. They were turning out really great.
“Good … but …” I said … “I meant all of it”
She was standing there in just her underpants and I was pointing my finger at them, lowering my finger, indicating to her to take her panties off too.
She didn’t react.
“All the cool kids are part of this club” I said.
“Even Cindy?” Alisha asked.
“Well, I can’t say without some assurance” I said and waved my hand again, encouraging her to take her underwear off.
She gave a tense smile as she lowered her panties and let them drop to the ground.
I took a few more pictures and checked the result on my phone. I got a hard on, but wasn’t sure if it was because of the pictures or the very naked Alisha standing right in front of me.
“So tell me!” Alisha said, standing naked in front of me.
“Only members can know who else is a member” I just said, leaving it up to her to ask.
“So, can I be a member!?” she asked.
“Well, the thing about being a member of this club is that once you’re a member you cannot tell anyone about the club and you can never leave the club!”
“Really? No one has ever told about the club?” she asked surprised, knowing how rumors have a tendency to spread.
“Well Alisha, tell me this, had you ever heard of the club before today?”. She shook her head. I knew that, since I just made up the club today, but it somehow proved my point.
“It only works because everyone who learns about the club have some leverage against them” I explained.
“Like these pictures?” she said, pointing to my phone.
“Well, yes and no” I said. “These pictures won’t be enough, I’ve already told you too much. You might as well get dressed again, I changed my mind”.
“No!” she said and stood demonstratively naked in front of me. “Let me be a member!”
“Well” I said and unzipped my pants “I need a picture of you with my penis in your mouth, that’s the only way to make sure”.
I moved closer to her and put my hand on her shoulder, I then started pushing her down on the floor. “Sit down” I said. She did. I put my penis near her mouth. “Put it in your mouth” I said. She did. “Suck it!”.
While she was sucking my dick, I was taking more pictures. “Over here” I said, making her look at the camera while sucking my dick. “That’s it”.
“When we are done” I said and sit in the couch. I put the camera on the table to record and asked her to come to me. “I cannot tell you more until I have more leverage” I said. She came to me. Without explaning anything in detail I positioned her on top of me and guided my cock to her pussy. To my surprise it slipped right in, she was dripping wet.
I started moving her up and down on my cock. When I got tired, I put her down on the couch and started fucking her missionary.
While she was moaning she said “Be careful, I’m not on the pill”.
I kept fucking her, just wanted her to be quiet and said “Yes I know, we know everything in the club”
“What?” she said “how could you know that, I just stopped and didn’t tell anyone!”
“Well … “ I said and didn’t continue. I didn’t know what to say.
“Well … ?” she asked.
“Well” I just said again. I continued fucking her and moments later I started cumming. I pulled out and offloaded most of the cum on her tits”
“Well …?” she asked again “how could you know”.
“Uhmm” I just said.
“You know what I think?” she said rhetorically “I think that there IS no club!”
I didn’t say anything.
She continued “Hah, I’m right, aren’t I?”
“Well I’m not falling for that!” she said and put her clothes back on and left.